Alan Kay talk at DePaul University (2012)
From Viewpoints Intelligent Archive
this
great honor is especially meaningful to me because
no one knows more to his research
community than i do and i feel
the same spirit of family and community in
the wonderful deep all commitments to
access to everyone and it takes a
village to help all of us succeed in
our dreams when i asked
about graduation speeches i was
told it is tradition to give advice and
to be darn quick about it
but
since we're all manifestly diverse
everyone needs somewhat
different advice and after all of
these years I'm still working on my own process so
I don't have any lofty pronouncements from my
own experience this is probably a relief
on the other hand
we are all the members of the same species and
part of what education with
the capital e should mean is for
us to gain some understanding and perspective on
ourselves so after
acquiring a real education in college
shouldn't we be able to give
the human race at least one piece of useful advice
what of
many perspectives on humanity
would you choose and what advice would you give
there's a lot of scientific evidence that
says our species has been on the planet
for at least 200,000 years an
anthropologists who
have studied thousands of societies around the world and
found that all have language
stories culture
religion music
dance art several
hundred categories of behaviors
at all a child born
into one culture and moved at birth to another will
grow up as a member of the receiving
culture we have to be very similar
for this to be possible so
despite all of our manifest differences
down deep we were also very similar and
what seems to differ from culture to culture are
not our categories but how each culture
fills them out for
we don't fight over whether we have beliefs about
the world but over what beliefs
so here's what strikes me about us even
though for hundreds of thousands of years we've
cared so much about our beliefs to fight for them
until very recently we humans
have just taken the world of our senses and of
our cultures as they seem with
almost no attempts to invent ways to
check if our perceptions and beliefs actually
hold water in
other words we humans live inside of our heads
to an astonishing degree so
much so that we resemble a creature in
a dream that only occasionally matches
up with the world that lives in we
live in a kind of a hallucination of our own devising
Francis Bacon pointed
this out in 1610 when
he called for methods to be developed to get around the
blindness caused by our genetics
how our individual brains
develop how we use language and how
we assimilate the beliefs of our culture's
this was part of the already started
invention of science which produced
example after example we're careful investigations
and new kinds of thinking's revealed
that many of our beliefs about the world did not hold
up we have been fooling ourselves
so the perspective on humanity I
would choose is that we are the species
that fools itself in fact
we even pay good money to be fooled and
we have been fooling ourselves for
our entire 200,000 years and
part of the nature of this foolery is that
we can see and that
what we think is there is what is there a
wonderful line and the Talmud
says we things not as they are
but as we are I've often wondered
what happened to that person Marshall
McLuhan the great canadian philosopher
said until I believe it I can't see it
but we need dreams
and imagination one
of my greatest heroes was Helen Keller
who was rendered blind and deaf
before she was two years old yet
became the first deafblind person to earn a college
degree at Radcliffe in
1904 in 1932
shortly after the empire state building was
built at the dawn of the depression
in amazingly less than a year as a
statement by its contractors about
what humans can do with purpose and will
Helen Keller who knew a lot about
purpose and will took a trip to the top
she was asked afterwards by
dr. John Finley what did you think of
the site when you're on top of
the empire building here are
a few extracts from the letter she wrote to Finley
I quote
frankly I was so entranced seeing
that I did not think
about the site if
there was a subconscious thought of it it
was in the nature of gratitude
to God for having given
the blind seeing minds as I
now recall the view i had from the Empire tower
I'm convinced that until
we have looked into darkness we cannot
know what a divine thing vision is I
will concede that my guide
saw a thousand things that escaped me from
the top of the empire building but
i am not envious for imagination
creates distances and horizons
that reach to the end of the world it
is as easy for the mind to think in stars as
in cobblestones it
was a thrilling experience to be whizzed in a
lift a quarter of a mile heavenward and to
see New York spread out like a marvelous tapestry
beneath us there was the Hudson
more like the flash of a sword blade than
a noble River the little island
of Manhattan set like a jewel in its nest of
rainbow waters stared up into
my face and the solar system circled
about my head why I thought
the Sun and stars are suburbs
of New York and I never knew it I see
in the Empire State Building something else
passionate skill arduous and
fearless idealism the tallest
building is a victory of imagination instead
of crouching close to the earth like a beast the
spirit of man soars to higher regions and
from this new point of Vantage he
looks upon the impossible with fortified
courage and dreams yet more significant enterprises
what did I see in here from the Empire
tower as I stood there are twinks to earth
and sky I saw a romantic structure
wrought by human brains and hands
that is to the burning I of the Sun
arrival luminary I saw it stand erect
and serene in the midst of storm and the
tumult of n elemental commotion
I heard the hammer of Thor ring when the shaft
began to rise upward I saw the unconquerable
steal the flash of testing
flames the sword like rivets I heard
the stream steam drills and pandemonium I
saw countless skilled workers welding
together that mighty symmetry I looked
up on the Marvel of frail yet indomitable hands
that lifted the tower to
its dominating height
when I first read that i said wow
I say it now every
human being is born with it potential
to learn to see as Helen Keller learned to
see with their hearts body spirits and
minds and to learn to be as vividly alive
and human as Helen Keller learned to be
our great gift is that
though we are the stuff that dreams are made of we
can invest those dreams with the clearer knowledge
brought by careful study beyond our simple
prejudices there's nothing more powerful and
imagination coupled with investigation
imagination allows us to dream
and conceive of better futures for us all
investigation finds the powers and knowledge to
make better futures happen so
I think my advice to our species would be we can't learn
to see until we admit we are blind in
other words let us learn
how to wake up from the slumbers of our nervous system culture
and beliefs try to find out what is going on
and what is really needed thank you